Friday, July 9, 2010
Last Days of Berlin
Memorial Assignment
With the amount of tragic history the city of Berlin has endured, it is appropriate to memorialize some of these events, people, and days. When such disastrous things take place, it is hard to decide whether to pay tribute to such a thing or not, and if so, how? The Nazi period and era of the Berlin Wall are two points in history in which the city of Berlin has had to struggle with these decisions.
The Nazi period was a dark time in Germany’s history. I think that the German’s have appropriately memorialized the things and people of that time. The Holocaust Memorial by Peter Eisenman pays tribute to those who lost their life during the Holocaust. I think this memorial is important in the fact that it doesn’t just remember the Jewish people that died but everyone including the gypsies, homosexuals, and a-socials. As Americans, for some reason, we focus on the Holocaust in terms of how the Jewish population was affected. It is important to realize and remember that the Holocaust included much more. The Jewish Museum memorializes in a way the entire history of the Jewish people. One particular exhibit focuses on the Jews killed during the Nazi period. This exhibit succeeded in stirring up strong emotions for these people. I didn’t necessarily agree in the way in which the artist evoked these emotions (walking on “faces” of the ones suffering). I don’t believe we as outside parties should have to feel responsible for what happened. The Nazi’s have been recognized and portrayed in an important way in various museums in Berlin. I think by recognizing this past allows people to learn from history and prevent these mistakes from happening in the future. I feel that recognizing the party in museums and not in open public memorials was a smart and appropriate decision. It is evident through the way they have dealt with Nazi memorialization that the German people have learned from this era and are aware of the possibility of Neo-Nazi’s trying to create an uprising.
In more recent history, the era of the Berlin Wall is still affecting the people of Berlin. This period of time is one that people would understandably want to forget. Again, I think it’s important to remember these points in history because it was an important part of what defined Berlin. It also allows people to remember how much progress they have made as a city and a people. The Wall Memorial, I feel, is small enough that residents and tourists can recognize the severity of the time, yet it has been removed enough so that it is not the intrusive object that it once was. I really appreciated how they marked where the entire wall used to be with the two rows of stones through the streets all around the city. It is a subtle thing acting as a scar on the face of the city. It tells a story, and adds to the palimpsestic qualities of the city. Checkpoint Charlie, however, was not much more than a tourist attraction, most tourists being American. I don’t feel like having the checkpoint still up with fake soldiers standing in front adds anything of importance to the Berliners’ dally lives. The Checkpoint Charlie Museum is very informative and allows people to understand how life was for Berliners during this difficult and divided time. This is still a touchy subject for the people of Berlin in many ways, and from an outsiders perspective they are able to work through some of their issues as a city through these memorials.
Monday, July 5, 2010
Reflections of The Wall Jumper
The book The Wall Jumper raises several issues about life in Berlin during the era of the Berlin Wall. The author really begins to shed light on how people went about their daily lives during this time. There were definitely strong attitudes amongst the people of the East and West that were described throughout the different stories. Surprisingly, it seemed that the attitudes of Easterners towards the Westerners and vice versa were very similar in nature. For example, the author accompanied his girlfriend to her family’s house in the East. They would talk about how bad life was on their side of the wall, and the girlfriend would reply with comments about how bad life was in the West. It seems that everyone thought that they were worse off than the others were. As the author jumps around from story to story, one thing that is fairly consistent is the depression among the people. Trying to imagine the people he describes in the airport, train stations, bars, etc., they all seem full of despair. I think the attitudes that the people had and the depression they were experiencing were major parts of why people began to jump the Wall – thinking life must be greener on the other side.
Another interesting point the author touches on is the idea of state versus fatherland and people as a nation versus political boundaries. He basically says that the state in which the Germans belong has not been old enough to call their fatherland, but their fatherland is no longer a state. Stating that you are German is a more of a statement of your people group and language rather than the political boundaries in which you live. I feel like at that time the Germans were at a loss for a national identity. One day you live in the same city and down the street from your family, and the next you live in two different countries. This separation wasn’t a choice for the people - they couldn’t choose whether to be an East German or West German based on their own political view points. In America, if we don’t like the way a city or state is run politically, we have the freedom to pick up and move somewhere else that is better suited (although that is not quite as extreme of a situation as Communism versus Capitalism). I feel that being an American has different connotations that the notion of what language you speak. The US is such a melting pot that you can speak any language and call yourself American. I feel that our nationality has more to do with boundaries and paper work than a people group. This has its advantages and disadvantages. I think this ideal may be the stem of our lack of national unity whereas Germans seem to be more unified as a nation because of their language, people group, and history that they have endured and overcome together.
czechy czechy czechy
Thursday, July 1, 2010
Thursday
Monday through Wednesday
Tuesday, June 29, 2010
"The Hills are Alive" - Weekend in Austria
Wednesday/Thursday - return to Berlin
Wednesday, June 23, 2010
Tuesday - Stuttgart
Stuttgart is famous for the Porsche. We started off our day drooling over the Porsche Museum. I didn’t personally care for the aesthetic of the building, but I did find it impressive. Basically the whole museum was lifted off the ground and supported by three “legs”. The cantilevering proved to be a structural feat. I think we all enjoyed getting to look at porsches all morning. They took you through the history of Porsche starting with the first models and ending with the latest and most impressive. I really enjoyed looking at the old ones. It was here, mom and dad, that I picked out your newest toys! Ha!
If seeing all the BMW’s and Porsche’s this trip hasn’t been enough car shopping, we went on over to the Mercedes Benz Museum next. This was definitely my favorite building of the day, and maybe in my top favorites for the trip. It was designed by UN Studio. They focused a lot on circulation. They set up the circulation in a double helix ramping system. Without seeing any diagrams, I was kind of confused about how it all worked, but it was definitely a unique museum experience. I hate going in museums that you have to back track through things to get to something else. They were able to prevent this from happening. They too started with the old(horse and buggy) and ended w/ the new. We didn’t hear as much about the cars on this tour as we did about the architecture. So, there are lots of things about the building I could comment on and that I liked, but I’ll keep it short. As you wound down throughout the helix, they allowed you to preview the next room you would enter. You kept winding down the ramp around the cars on show and then you were able to mingle amongst the cars once you hit the floor. This building has a unique smoke removal system that won them a spot in the Guinness Book of World Records. Basically the entire museum circles around a central atrium and has doors that open up to the space in the event of a fire. There is a vent at the top center of the atrium that along with other mechanisms sucks all of the smoke out of the exhibition spaces into the center and creates a “tornado” in order to get the smoke out of the building. Pretty ingenious if you ask me.
The last thing we saw was a double house by Le Corbusier – the Father of Modernism. I’ve seen one of his houses while in France (Villa Savoye for those of you that are architecturally savvy), so I was able to compare this house to that. It is so apparent in his designs and how one would live in these spaces his ideal of a house being a “machine for living”. From the way you open the doors, to the way you sleep, everything makes you feel as if you are operating a machine in order to do daily things. Its not about waking up in your bedroom and moving from one programmed room to the next to do what you need to do in a day. Its about changing the one room to perform each different function. One of the major comparisons I noticed, was that this house was much more compact than Villa Savoye. I don’t know if this has to do with the area in which it is built (this house being in a denser area) or what. Another aspect I thought was interesting were the colors he used. A brown color was on the main wall with a deep red door, and a recessed part of the wall was painted a sky-ish blue. After taking art history and knowing Corbu was an artist himself, this color pallete makes a lot of sense. When painting, warm colors are supposed to be in the foreground while cool colors are to be in the background and fade away. He allows the walls to become not just pretty colors, but a livable piece of art.
CULTURE
Just a couple random things:
During the excursion this week, I’ve realized that not only does our apartment in Berlin do this, but so does every other hotel in Germany. I don’t remember it being like this in Paris/France, so I’m wondering if its just a German thing. Anyway, German linens are different. Instead of sleeping with a fitted sheet, a normal sheet, and then a comforter, they sleep on top of a normal sheet that is tucked in to function as a fitted sheet and then just cover up with a down feather duvet. So, its really like sleeping w/ no sheets. Their pillows aren’t as firm. They are a little bigger but the foam is much looser. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing … just different. And I’m definitely a fan of down feathers!
Monday - from Munich to Stuttgart
We set out early and headed towards Stuttgart (pronounced stootgart not like Stuttgart, Arkansas). We stopped on the way at the Vitra Campus. Vitra is a furniture company that has set up a campus of different buildings done by super star architects. Its kind of like a Disney World Epcot Center for architects. There was a chair museum done by Frank Gehrey - a turning point project for him going from angular to curvy. Tadao Ando did a conference center that contrasted with the complexity of Gehrey’s project. I loved the craftsmanship of the concrete - so smooth and clean. His site placement was really nice – allowing you to feel like the building was by itself. Herzog and de Meuron just finished the VitraHaus – their new products store/showrooms. The outside of their building looked simple in form, but the inside was rather complex. The outside contrasted again with Gehrey’s white museum with a dark charcoal color. The inside was all white allowing the furniture to be the focal point. They framed views of the surrounding vineyards and buildings. The difference b/w the interior and exterior really allows the interior to glow at night. They are one of my favorite firms b/c they have a reason behind everything that they do. I wish I had had more time to explore the complexities of this project. We were able to see other projects on the campus by Nicholas Grimshaw, Alvaro Siza, and Buckminster Fuller. We also saw the Vitra Fire Station by Zaha Hadid – one of her first realized projects. There were some pros and cons about this building. The coolest thing probably being the staircase…. Each step was cantilevered from the wall. This campus was a really dense experience seeing so many key architects at once all the while trying to admire the awesome furniture!
We hit the road again the next stop being the Hohenzollern Castle. This is the family that held the monarch crowns for so many years throughout German history. (Fredrick the Great, Wilhelm II who was responsible for WWI, etc) This was really fun to see. It was so picturesque with amazing views over the “kingdom”. The castle is actually still private property of the current head of the Holhenzollern family. He lives in Berlin in a rented flat…. Quite a different scene from the mideival/gothic castle! The girls decided we could just fake some papers of aristocracy and go marry into the royal family. J haha. We got to climb to the top of the tower at the top of this mountain. The sun was getting ready to set w/ rays peeking through the clouds – the word majestic was all I could think of.
The drive was also gorgeous. We’d pass by lots of lovely little German villages set into the hills. We also went through the infamous black forest. The trees were pretty dark, so I’m guessing that’s where the name comes from, but not really sure. We finally arrived in Stuttgart. We decided very quickly that this is the Detroit of Germany. Its very industrial and our hotel is in a really random area of town. We had to find food around 10 pm which was a hard task in this area. We ended up at a Chinese restaurant where no one spoke a word of English. We had trouble deciphering the German described Chinese food. That was an interesting task. We’ve learned that pointing and hoping for the best is sometimes the best way to go about the language barrier.
Sunday - Munich
Dachau concentration camp- We started our day by going to one of the first concentration camps. This was, as expected, incredibly moving and sobering. Just to be in the presence of where all of these awful things took place made my heart ache for these people. Since Dachau was one of the first concentration camps, it was referenced in everyday conversation…. “Shut up or you’ll go to Dachau” was a common phrase of the day among Jewish people or a-social groups. I don’t really want to go into detail about everything they did there, but I’ll share some things I didn’t realize beforehand. I didn’t realize that this particular camp was for mostly men. I guess I hadn’t thought about people being separated by groups for any particular camp from another. We learned how incredibly hard life was for the prisoners at the camp. They had to make their straw beds every morning. They were in bunk beds that were all connected, and if one bed was so much as a millimeter taller than another they would be punished. If a speck of dirt was found on the floor – punished. Their punishment was often to have their arms tied behind their back and then hung from their wrists for an hour. I also didn’t know that there was a difference b/w a concentration camp and extermination camp. Dachau did have a gas chamber and crematorium but it was said to not have been used for mass murder like you think of. We were able to go in the gas chamber. This was a pretty chilling experience that just brought tears to my eyes, but its something that is good for people to see. Like one of our professors was saying, we learn so much about this and see so many pictures in history books, museums, movies, etc. that we are almost desensitized to it, but once you are there seeing images taken from where you are standing, it really hits home.
We also were able to see a Coop Himmelblau project - the BMW Welt. This is a well known project in the architectural world mainly known for a “whirlwind” cone in the front of the building. Inside was basically a really fancy dealership. There was a restaurant and snack bar, and a parts and souvenir shop. It also contained a interactive museum of sorts that let people understand the different technologies that bmw uses. It was a fun little area, and kids were climbing all over the place. We got to go behind scenes for a bit and see the storage area for the cars. The was an interesting space. You don’t think about how places like this store hundreds of cars. This was basically a huge scale technological version of cubby holes. There were mechanical pieces that lifted cars and turned them to get them in and out of the right hole.
Across from BMW Welt was the 1972 Olympic Park. Being built in the 70’s, it is a little dated now, as far as wear and tear, but still very modern and really quite timeless stylistically. You’ve all seen tent/canvas like structures that are held up by tension. This was a glass/plastic version of one of those tents. The structure of these buildings was pretty incredible and very complicated. It was neat to see a different material used as a fabric connecting these different areas together. The structure that was brought to the ground was massive and acted as a play area for kids (and adults for that matter) to climb or sit on. This enabled the building to become very interactive, and that is something we all strive for as architects (or we should in my opinion). Another thing I was impressed with was how many people were still using the space. It was drizzling and honestly yucky outside, yet there were still lots of people riding bikes, running, swimming in the pool, and just hanging out. I think that is a really important thing to think about not only in terms of Olympic parks for later use, but what our projects can do In the future and how they can be adapted to serve another function. I think the fact that there are so many people still using the space speaks a lot about the successfulness of this project.
Later a group of us went to a architecturally significant church for a Bach concert – Herz-Jesu Kirche by ASW Architects. I don’t care if you like modern architecture or not, this church is beautiful. The exterior is a glass cube. Once you enter the space there is a wooden cube within the glass cube offset enough for circulation in between. The wooden cube is made of louvers. Inside the chapel light gets filtered through the translucent glass and then through the louvers. It was so nice. I was also excited about the Bach concert. Hearing classical music in the heart of its birthplace was one of my goals for this trip…. Check! The concert was on the organ and quite impressive. I was glad I got to experience that.
MUNICH CULTURE: We got to eat at a local Bavarian restaurant. I had a dish that had potatoes with chicken on top sprinkled with cheese, bacon, mushrooms, and lots of really good and tasty spices. That has been my favorite dish so far! Yummmm Munich strangely reminded me of Dallas. We didn’t get to experience a lot of the town life, but just driving around it looked like a nice place to live. It’s a decent size city, but with the city feel of Dallas instead of the hustle and bustle of New York.
Saturday - Nurnburg
We got up early Saturday morning and drove to Nurnberg. We went specifically to see the oldest biggest cookoo clock on a church and the Nazi Rally parade grounds, but when we got there we discovered even more. We got into town early so we got to do a little exploring before noon when the clock had its big “show”. This church was built in a plaza where the town had set up a market of fresh foods. We turned the corner and found a really old castle. So, we went up to it and stumbled across a panoramic view of the town. It was really pretty. Nurnberg was such a quaint little town (at least the historic part). When you think of German cottages and towns, this is what you think of. (Mom and Dad – I’m adding this town to your “must see” list!) There were tons of tourists. Everyone was just walking through the streets and when a car came through they just stopped and waited till people were out of their way. We made sure we made it back to the plaza to watch the clock, and while you’re watching it, it seems rather anti-climatic. But, you have to realize that it was a rather big feat for the 1500’s. We ate lunch at a little place next to the plaza and another big old church. I had some sausages w/ sauerkraut…which actually was not too bad I might add. Trey beat me for the most adventurous eater award… he ate cow tongue for lunch. We couldn’t decide if that or the head cheese that I ate last week was worse, but the fact that I didn’t know what I was ordering when I ate the head cheese kicked me out of the running. After lunch we went inside the church and admired the honest gothic architecture.
Next, we went to the Nazi Parade Grounds. This was a strange experience. Hitler had huge plans for this place but they lost the war before much of it was realized. So, it was kind of like seeing Roman ruins in a way only the “ruins” parts were because they hadn’t finished constructing not because they had been around so long. The chilling part was to think that every brick that was laid was done so by Jewish prisoners. The first building was an arena like structure that wasn’t completed. Everything about it was massive and brutal – provoking the idea of power. We also walked down the stone road that the Nazi’s marched down and then stood where Hitler stood to make his speeches. That was kind of a numbing experience. Seeing all of this let me realize what the Nazis were thinking and how they got more people to join along in their thought. Our guide talked about how people reacted to Hitler in his rise of power. He said people including Hitler himself treated him like a god – pictures hanging in the living room of people’s homes, his face being in the wrapper of chocolate candy, when kids acted up parents would tell them that the Furher was watching them. We went through a museum that explained kind of the rise and fall of the Nazi party. They had lots of pictures and videos of rallies happening in the plaza of Nurnberg where we stood earlier that day.
After touring the grounds, we headed to Munich in time walk around town before dark. We’re spending a lot of time on the bus, but everything we’re seeing this week is fairly significant and worth the drive. We have a pretty awesome bus driver too. We’ve got a big charter bus that she just weaves in and out of these tiny European roads like driving a mini-cooper or something. We’ve all been amazed at her turning capabilities. We have been within centimeters of bikes, cars, light poles, street signs, buildings, and not had a single scratch. Now, there’s a cultural thing for you! I guess if you grow up driving over here you learn how to maneuver cars really well.
South Germany Excursion - Friday - Leipzig
Bauhaus
This building is in Dessau. It was originally a design school started and designed by Walter Gropius. This building is THE seminal building to launch the International style and thought. This school was unique in many ways for its time: they allowed women to learn in the same environment as men; a dormitory was attached to the school - the first where students could work and live in the same structure; and an entire façade of glass with no columns. One of my favorite parts of this building was the window details with how they opened.
BMW Plant
The central part of the plant was designed by Zaha Hadid. The factory is set up in a way that production is optimized w/ a central space (offices, cafeteria, business, etc) with the factories and production shops stemming from it. Throughout the central space, conveyer belts are running overhead with shells of partially made cars passing by. We got to go into the factory and watch cars go down the assembly lines. At some points robots are the only things putting pieces together. That was really fun to watch. They were huge machines but had human-like motions. We weren’t allowed to take pictures back there, but I probably could have watched those things work for hours. The tour guide said they complete 740 cars a day each car taking a total of 37 hours each. It was interesting to see how the design of the building helped make the production and function of the business run more efficiently.
Leipzig
This town we found not to be as inviting as Berlin and “Sassy Town”. We were too far away from the town center to experience any nightlife. There were lots of boarded up windows, graffiti, etc. that made us feel like we didn’t need to go exploring at night. We ended up watching a soccer game in the lobby. Germany lost their game that day, and we think that put a damper on the people’s attitudes. Even though we didn’t understand a word that was said, you could tell everyone that was interviewed on tv was really sad and upset about the loss.